也几天了，看的人也多了，吵来吵去干脆评分摸个底呗。

投票项目(单选 参与人数 530)
1 1烂片渣作 15(2.83%)
2 2全面不行 1(0.19%)
3 3浪费时间 7(1.32%)
4 4水平不够 7(1.32%)
5 5勉强及格 22(4.15%)
6 6平淡无奇 32(6.04%)
7 7高于预期 124(23.40%)
8 8良心佳作 181(34.15%)
9 9堪称炸裂 110(20.75%)
10 10爆燃最高 31(5.85%)

[投票已经结束]

posted by wap, platform: Meizu 魅蓝 METAL
- 得过且过 2019-2-7 21:33 通过手机版投票给"7高于预期"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- 农农 2019-2-7 21:33 通过手机版投票给"7高于预期"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- 莫言 2019-2-7 21:33 通过手机版投了票。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- seablue 2019-2-7 21:35 通过手机版投票给"8良心佳作"。

其实应该打9分，这部片子平心而论有太多不足，镜头，剪辑，主演，预算，都是不足，但是在中国的科幻电影中，确实是里程碑式的作品。所以我心中应该是8.5。

希望今后的中国科幻电影都能以此为标杆制作，就棒了。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- hwh123 2019-2-7 21:37 通过手机版投票给"8良心佳作"。

10 不说其他的，看看同期的其他电影是什么辣鸡

posted by wap, platform: Android
- imissrain 2019-2-7 21:42 通过手机版投票给"8良心佳作"。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- scyscy 2019-2-7 21:42 通过手机版投票给"9堪称炸裂"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- xxxyz 2019-2-7 21:46 通过手机版投票给"8良心佳作"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- 第七个男孩 2019-2-7 21:46 通过手机版投票给"8良心佳作"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- zelda_ch 2019-2-7 21:47 通过手机版投了票。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- 卡比兽 2019-2-7 22:04 通过手机版投了票。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- fujin 2019-2-7 22:05 通过手机版投票给"8良心佳作"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- jiangpeng6 2019-2-7 22:13 通过手机版投票给"7高于预期"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- tyfsam 2019-2-7 22:13 通过手机版投票给"8良心佳作"。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- 湿兄 2019-2-7 22:14 通过手机版投票给"10爆燃最高"。

国产电影的标杆

posted by wap, platform: VIVO
- dwkingwang 2019-2-7 22:14 通过手机版投票给"7高于预期"。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- 九阳游侠 2019-2-7 22:20 通过手机版投票给"7高于预期"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- 黑熊精 2019-2-7 22:37 通过手机版投了票。

posted by wap, platform: VIVO
- jfjfjfjf 2019-2-7 22:37 通过手机版投票给"9堪称炸裂"。

posted by wap, platform: Chrome
- wenzai 2019-2-7 22:39 通过手机版投票给"8良心佳作"。

posted by wap, platform: Android
7.8吧

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- edwang 2019-2-7 22:42 通过手机版投票给"9堪称炸裂"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
大大超出预期，8分没问题

posted by wap, platform: Android
- sonicae86 2019-2-7 22:50 通过手机版投票给"7高于预期"。

posted by wap, platform: Android
演员太差没法洗减2分，不然九分起步。

posted by wap, platform: 小米
- glsm 2019-2-7 22:52 通过手机版投票给"9堪称炸裂"。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- xsegaxhiss 2019-2-7 22:52 通过手机版投票给"8良心佳作"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- 动感超人 2019-2-7 23:00 通过手机版投了票。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- leonz99 2019-2-7 23:00 通过手机版投票给"9堪称炸裂"。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- kelaredbull 2019-2-7 23:03 通过手机版投票给"9堪称炸裂"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
估计最后和豆瓣差不多
还是挺准的

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- mouseguard 2019-2-7 23:04 通过手机版投票给"10爆燃最高"。

posted by wap, platform: Android
http://sciencefiction.com/2019/02/06/movie-review-wandering-earth/
这是国外的影评，大家不妨看一下。作者真的在文章最后加上了中国科幻电影里程碑的字样。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- zdztony 2019-2-7 23:23 通过手机版投票给"8良心佳作"。

。。。。

posted by wap, platform: Chrome
这个地址被墙了 可否贴回来 谢谢

posted by wap, platform: VIVO
- ggggfr 2019-2-7 23:27 通过手机版投了票。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- cywater2000 2019-2-7 23:29 通过手机版投票给"8良心佳作"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- sun4me 2019-2-7 23:30 通过手机版投票给"9堪称炸裂"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- iloveps2 2019-2-7 23:30 通过手机版投票给"9堪称炸裂"。

posted by wap, platform: 小米
- 放浪的无责任男 2019-2-7 23:32 通过手机版投票给"8良心佳作"。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- 看风听水 2019-2-7 23:49 通过手机版投票给"9堪称炸裂"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- 神刀飞飞 2019-2-7 23:50 通过手机版投票给"8良心佳作"。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- 忍者大师 2019-2-7 23:52 通过手机版投票给"9堪称炸裂"。

不错

posted by wap, platform: 小米NOTE
- heijz023 2019-2-7 23:53 通过手机版投票给"7高于预期"。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- fetter2005 2019-2-7 23:54 通过手机版投票给"9堪称炸裂"。

posted by wap, platform: Android
- 春熙 2019-2-7 23:55 通过手机版投票给"7高于预期"。

posted by wap, platform: iPhone
- 去日留痕 2019-2-7 23:55 通过手机版投票给"9堪称炸裂"。

posted by wap, platform: Android
Just when we thought we’d figured out how to address global warming, it turns out that the sun has gone rogue and in less than a century it’s going to destroy Earth and eventually expand to the size of our solar system. We can’t build enough space stations to save mankind and we can’t colonize another planet since they’re all going to be destroyed too. But what if we built thousands of massive rocket thrusters at key spots on the planet and shot the entire planet out of the solar system and onward to the Sol-like sun a 2,500 year journey away?

That’s the fantastic and fascinating premise of the new Chinese made sci-fi blockbuster ‘The Wandering Earth’ and it’s an idea so crazy that might just work. Thousands of thrusters and massive underground cities to ensure billions of people around the world can survive and breed, generation after generation, until the planet can be neatly repositioned in the new system. Meanwhile, everything is utter chaos and when the rotation of the Earth is stopped so that the thrusters can push our planet in the right direction, it’s a smart thing to be 500m underground in one of the cities.

Great sci-fi stories are about people, not just technology, however, and ‘The Wandering Earth’ centers on three generations of a Chinese family: grandfather, father Liu Peiqiang (Wu Jing), and son Liu Qi (Qu Chuxiao). The film opens as the United Earth Government announces its plans to save Earth and mankind: To shoot out of the solar system. Leading the journey will be a massive space station that will ensure safe travels. It’s Liu Peiqiang who’s volunteered to be part of the space station staff, a job that will keep him in space for almost twenty years. Meanwhile, his 7 year old son Liu Qi doesn’t really understand what’s going on. Zoom forward 17 years and things have gotten rough, but the Earth is indeed on its journey out of our system; it’s poised to slingshot past Jupiter and use the planet’s gravitational pull to speed up the journey.

the wandering earth

By this point, Liu Qi has become a brilliant but highly cynical tech who dabbles in creating strange technologies and yearns for the father he’s never known. His mother, in the way of all drama, passed away many years earlier, so he’s been raised by his grandfather. Along the way an orphan girl Han Duo (Zhao Jinmai) has been adopted by the family, Qi’s adopted sister. She’s a teenager and her ceaseless gum chewing and occasional whining are one of the few humanizing elements of this male-heavy cast.

So they’re flying past Jupiter and it’s all looking good for the gravity slingshot. Until it isn’t and everyone realizes with some alarm that the Earth has been almost 10-degrees off course and is being pulled into Jupiter’s massive gravity not flung past it. Worse, it’s knocked almost all of the planetary thrusters offline! That’s the main plot element around which everything else revolves and it’s up to Liu Qi, Han Dao, tough military captain Wang Lei (Li Guangjie), scientist Li Yiyi (Zhang Yichi) and half-Australian, half-Chinese sidekick Tim (Mike Sui) to get one of the big equatorial thrusters online before it’s too late.

There’s a lot to like about this fast-moving adventure sci-fi epic, from the sheer audacity of the core storyline to the gorgeous sets and external shots, to the gritty realism of the underground cities. Like all good science fiction, it asks the viewer to ponder some fundamental questions about who should be saved, what cost we’re willing to pay to survive, and what plans we might create if we’re really heading to heck in a handbasket, however big or small. The visual effects are stunning and rival the best of Hollywood’s sci-fi epics. That’s no surprise when visual effects teams like Base FX, Pixomondo, Bottleship FX, Weta, and Macrograph were involved. There’s also a 3D IMAX version that I managed to catch (it was only in US theaters for two days before being bumped off the screens by the Lego movie) and it was lush and entirely immersive on the huge screen. The deep frozen and half-destroyed skylines of the Chinese cities were terrific.

But ‘The Wandering Earth’ isn’t great science fiction. Modern film audiences are sophisticated enough to find a story that ignores the most basic of physics jarring. A nerdy scientist who could explain how the Earth still had an atmosphere once it stopped spinning or how we could build cities big enough to house over three billion humans that are 500m underground would have solved the narrative problem. Also, the temperature on the Earth’s surface should be absolute zero if we’re racing through deep space too; how is it vehicles can still function on that surface? And the final solution (no spoilers here!) really doesn’t hold water and would not have a happy ending.

The acting is all over the place too. At times teen Han Duo (known in the film as Duoduo) acts like a whiny toddler, just to turn around a few minutes later to inspire everyone with a stirring speech. I was also intrigued by the tension between Liu Qi and his long-absent father Liu Peiqiang, but the film offered little insight into either of their feelings about this tragic separation. As with so many other sci-fi films, we’re left asking the question of whether a grand story and beautiful visual effects are sufficient to create a great movie. And as with too many, the answer is “not really”.

And then there’s the political side of the film, which is fascinating. There are no Americans in the story. None. The only American flag we see is draped over a coffin, in fact. The United Earth Government has Russians, French, English and other nations represented, but no Americans. Except for MOSS, that is. And who’s MOSS? The sentient computer system that runs the space station. Think HAL from 2001: A Space Odyssey and you’ll be on the right track.

All of this leads to the observation that the experience for me as an American watching ‘The Wandering Earth’ was undoubtedly similar to that of a Chinese film aficionado watching an American sci-fi blockbuster and wondering why China never shows up, Chinese actors are never on screen, and somehow Chinese ingenuity and perseverance never seems to help save the day. Quid pro quo, I suppose.

The film is also in Mandarin Chinese with English subtitles and those subtitles move fast! There’s a lot of dialog and you really have to pay attention to catch all the nuances, which is too bad because you’re really going to want to be enjoying the gorgeous visuals and effects, whether in space, on the space station or back on a very, very chill Earth. Perhaps there’ll be a dubbed version at some point in the future, but until then, be prepared (or learn Chinese quick).

Finally, with all of that said, I still enjoyed ‘The Wandering Earth.’ It’s a massive, exciting concept and a solid tension-building story that will keep you on the edge of your seat as Jupiter exerts more and more gravitational pull on our little planet. Could we realistically push Earth into a new universe? Does that really matter when you’re in the theater seeking some entertainment? I say go see it and enjoy a wholly different science fiction epic that marks a milestone in Chinese cinema.





FacebookTwitterGoogle+Pinterest分享
TAGS:MOVIE REVIEWTHE WANDERING EARTH

DAVE TAYLORDave has been a sci-fi geek forever. His favorite book in high school was “Dune” and once he saw the first “Star Wars” film (aka Part IV: A New Hope), his obsession with sci-fi entertainment media was a lock. He has terrestrial degrees in computer science, education and an MBA, and has been involved with the consumer electronics industry for many years. In addition to his work as a tech support oracle at the popular AskDaveTaylor.com he’s also a parenting blogger at GoFatherhood.com.